10 August 2008
TWIP Photo Book Reviews #19 Guide to High Dynamic Range Digital Photography
Posted by
Scott under:
Photo Book Reviews
Author: Ferrell McCollough
Complete Guide to High Dynamic Range Digital Photography
Publisher: Lark Books (Sterling Publishing Co.)
Review by Conrad J. Obregon
High Dynamic Range (HDR) Photography presents an opportunity to capture pictures that look more like the real world. Even though this book is not perfect, the subject is important enough for serious photographers to take the time to read the book and experiment with the technique.
Because the range of light that the human eye can see is far greater than what cameras can photograph, it’s not uncommon for photographs to show impenetrable shadows or burnt out highlights where the human eye saw detail. Photographers have had some success ameliorating the condition with things like levels and merging and masking in Photoshop. Now HDR promises to extend the light range a great deal further.
After an overview of HDR photography, the author discusses methods of capturing images for HDR processing. He next presents a discussion of two major tools of HDR photography, merging and tone mapping, and then describes the processing of an image in one of the HDR programs, Photomatix Pro. Next he describes the HDR programs available (including Photoshop’s apparently second-rate facility) and compares the results of the different programs using several images. The book then discusses post processing of the HDR image, and provides additional tips on making the original capture. The author finishes up by describing special techniques like flash merging, panoramas and single image HDR processing. Sprinkled throughout the book are the portfolios of several HDR artists.
Because I found it difficult to grasp the processing techniques just from the written word, I downloaded trial versions of some of the available HDR programs, and I prepared a set of photographs with different exposure values to use whenever McCollough suggested a particular technique. Even though I felt that McCollough could have given more explicit instructions on the use of the various converters, I was able to create images that demonstrated a far greater range of light then any individual image I had captured, or then images that I was able to adjust in Photoshop.
Because our eyes have become accustomed to the limited range of standard photographs, many of the author’s photographs appeared to be too vivid, although when I considered the sample HDR images I had created, I realized that they seemed to reflect the actual light values I had seen when taking the pictures. On the other hand McCollough has no objection to pushing the range of light beyond what the human eye can see to create surrealistic pictures for artistic impact.
I wish that, rather then providing a step-by-step explanation of processing of an image in Photomatix Pro, the author had provided an actual tutorial that the reader could follow on his or her own computer, using downloaded images that the author provided. I guess I really want a book called “the Complete Guide to Photomatix Pro”. On the other hand I would also have liked to see full demonstrations of the other available software, similar to the demonstrations provided in “Mastering HDR Photography” by Michael Freeman.
Because HDR works best where there is no subject movement, the techniques contained in this book are most likely to be applicable to landscape and still life photography. However, it appears there are also opportunities in single image HDR photography for moving subjects.
I am certain that as HDR matures we will be presented with many volumes that can show us how to use this technology, but for now at least, this an excellent place to start.
6 Comments so far...
Lee Says:
10 August 2008 at 8:50 am.
Thanks for this review, I have put in my basket at Amazon. I love the HDR technique although I only discovered it in the last 6 months, so I would like to read up on the subject. I now shoot almost exclusively bracketed exposures in RAW. this means thay if I can’t dodge and burn my way out of a poor capture I can still get the all the light information I need for a reasonable final product. If the central exposure is good enough, I just bin the 2 other exposures… the joy of shooting digital!
James M. Press Says:
10 August 2008 at 3:03 pm.
Very nice review.
I purchased this book and found it very helpful in understanding the process of HDR photography, although it’s still a real hit-or-miss process for me. I agree with Mr. Obregon in that what I really would like to see is a “…Complete Guide to Photomatix Pro”.
Most HDR photography I have seen tends toward the “surrealistic” effects one can achieve (which I do enjoy), but if you want to see the Real potential of HDR photography, take a look at the work of Sergio Parisi on flickr. This is someone that has truly mastered HDR. His landscape and still life HDR photography is truly amazing.
Alec Says:
10 August 2008 at 5:29 pm.
Just finished the book, which I enjoyed.
He explains the principles of HDR very well and in a way which is easy to understand.
There is a chapter on PhotomatixPro, but I’m still looking for the “Complete Guide”.
Still can’t make up my mind whether I like HDR photos.
I highly recommend the book.
Steve Says:
11 August 2008 at 9:12 am.
If you are looking for another excellent guide to HDRI with an in depth guide to using Photomatix Pro, take a look at Christian Bloch’s The HDRI Handbook (rockynook press).
Jason Hatfield Says:
12 August 2008 at 6:22 am.
Hopefully cameras will soon shoot images with a dynamic range comparable to what our eyes see and we won’t have as much need for HDR programs.
Learn Photography for Free? » Alaminos National High School Classmates Says:
13 August 2008 at 5:21 am.
[...] out book reviews, be sure to check TWIP Photo. They have 19 reviews to date, the latest one the High Dynamic Range book by Ferrell McCollough. « WEN the right product for your Hair care | [...]
